The Pilgrim

North Marston, Buckinghamshire

Best Local Restaurant

Rating: Good

Modern British | Pub

Overall Rating: Good

Uniqueness: Good

Deliciousness: Good

Warmth: Very Good

Strength of recommendation: Very Good

With regulars filling the bar on a warm weekday evening, and more chewing the cud outside in the huge grassy beer garden, it's clear that the folk of North Marston cherish their classic village pub. Low beams, scrubbed pine furniture and various nooks and crannies combine to make a cosy haven, where incomers are also welcomed by cheery, informal staff. As well as a lauded Sunday roast, the kitchen delivers a winter menu and a summer ‘garden’ menu (dishes change weekly), both incorporating snacks and larger tapas-style plates for sharing. Flavour-packed Anglo-Mediterranean ideas predominated at our visit. A meaty assortment of devilled mushrooms in creamy mustard sauce arrived on a slice of sourdough, as did a long-simmered vegetable ragù, made appealingly nutty with walnuts. Luscious dollops of burrata were another highlight, matched with red-pepper tapenade and a crunchy mixed-seed dukkah. Larger dishes might include flavoursome grilled lamb kofte (though opinion was divided about the slightly sweet applewood-smoked yoghurt accompaniment), and a wonderful hearty bowl of mussels in tomato sauce generously leavened with ’nduja. Puddings tend to be classics such as a rich panna cotta, served with tangy raspberry compôte and fresh raspberries. Local ales, proper draught cider and a refreshingly priced, varied wine list add to the appeal, while a soundtrack of Chicago blues speaks of the owners' enthusiasm for music. Note that it's bar food only during the monthly open-mic and quiz nights, while the regular summer barbecues at this admirable community-focused pub are ‘a treat not to be missed’.

Rating: Good

Modern British | Pub

Overall Rating: Good

Uniqueness: Good

Deliciousness: Good

Warmth: Very Good

Strength of recommendation: Very Good

Dining Information:

Parking, Family friendly, Dog friendly

25 High Street, North Marston, Buckinghamshire MK18 3PD

01296 670969